Happy short-term rental guests enjoying a clean, stylish home—representing a 5-star guest experience in 2025.

Hosting Like a Pro in 2025: Mastering the Short-Term Rental Guest Experience

March 31, 20254 min read

Hosting Your Guests: Best Practices for a Smooth Stay 

Did you know that 70% of guests judge their experience based on the communication they received before their stay? In the world of short-term rentals, the guest experience starts way before they step through your door. If you're looking to elevate your hosting game, ensuring a seamless guest experience is paramount. In this post, we’ll dive into crucial strategies such as effective guest screening, handling inquiries efficiently, establishing open communication through welcome calls, managing security deposits, and gathering post-stay feedback. Mastering these elements will not only maximize your property's potential but also pave the way for repeat business and stellar reviews. 

1. Guest Screening: The Foundation of a Positive Experience 

Before any booking is confirmed, effective guest screening ensures you choose guests who are likely to respect your property and follow the house rules. 

  • Why Is Guest Screening Important? 
    Proper guest screening protects your rental property from potential damage and reduces issues during the stay. By vetting guests thoroughly, you ensure a safer stay and an overall better experience for everyone involved. 

  • Methods for Screening Guests: 

  • Direct Communication: Engage with potential guests through messaging platforms. Ask questions that clarify their intent and background regarding their stay. At Stronghold, we have welcome call with every guest to explain the rules, and answer guests’ questions. 

  • Check Reviews: Platforms often detail previous guest feedback; pay close attention to reviews focusing on communication and adherence to house rules. 

Public Records Search / Background Check: Criminal court records are public. You can search them yourself or hire a background check service to find out if guests have a criminal history before they stay at your property. 

2. Handling Inquiries: Prompt and Professional Response 

In the competitive market of short-term rentals, timely responses can make or break a reservation. 

  • Best Practices for Inquiry Handling: 

  • Be Prompt: Aim to respond to inquiries within an hour. Use your phone's notifications or an app to manage your communication on-the-go. 

  • Provide Comprehensive Information: Make your listing details as robust as possible. Include amenities, location information, and specific rules to reduce repetitive questions. 

  • Engage Through Language: Use a warm, inviting tone to make guests feel welcome. This approach ensures they envision their stay with you right from the beginning. 

3. Welcome Call: Fostering Open Communication 

Once a guest books, consider making a welcome call. This strategy goes beyond the standard email confirmation. 

  • What to Cover in a Welcome Call: 

  • Confirm Details: Ensure all guest details are correct, including arrival times and the total number of guests. 

  • Explain Rules Clearly: Go over critical house rules, check-in procedures, and contact information should any issues arise. 

  • Encourage Questions: By engaging guests in a dialogue, you provide opportunities for them to express concerns or ask questions. This sets a tone of openness and trust. 

4. Security Deposits: Ensuring Responsibility and Care 

Establishing a security deposit can be an effective strategy to protect your investment. This is OPTIONAL. Right now, we have NO DEPOSIT for Airbnb, and $500 deposit for direct bookings and VRBO guests. 

  • Why a Security Deposit Matters: 
    It gives guests an additional incentive to treat the property with care, understanding that their deposit may be affected by any damages. 

  • Best Practices for Handling Security Deposits: 

  • Clarity in Terms: Be upfront about the amount, when it's collected, and under what circumstances it is refundable. 

  • Use Trusted Platforms: Use reliable booking platforms that simplify the transaction process. 

5. Party & Rule Monitoring: Keeping It Under Control 

Hosts often face the challenge of unsupervised parties or rule violations during a guest's stay. 

  • Tips for Monitoring House Rules: 

  • Use Smart Technology: Security cameras and noise monitoring devices respect privacy while helping manage expected noise levels and excessive disturbances. 

  • Foster a Trusted Environment: Encourage guests to self-report issues or violations and address any disturbances swiftly to maintain the vibe of your rental. 

6. Post-Stay Feedback: The Key to Continuous Improvement 

Feedback from guests is invaluable for refining your rental practices and ensuring future success. 

  • How to Solicit Feedback: 

  • Follow Up Promptly: Contact guests shortly after their stay with a personalized message seeking their inputs. 

  • Use Surveys: A structured survey collection method allows easy data analysis while capturing guest sentiments. 

7. Case Study Resolution: Handling Complications with Grace 

Despite your best efforts, issues may arise during a guest's stay. How you handle these incidents can significantly affect your long-term reputation. 

  • Strategies for Effective Resolution: 

  • Stay Calm and Professional: Approach each issue as a problem to be solved rather than a personal affront. 

  • Provide Compensation When Warranted: Be prepared to offer partial refund or alternative accommodations where justified to ensure guest satisfaction. 

  • Learn and Adapt: Every situation should teach you something. Analyze what went wrong to prevent future occurrences. 

Download the Hosting Like a Pro in 2025 Mastering the Short-Term Rental Guest Experience and use it to elevate your guest experience and unlock more 5-star reviews in 2025. Download Link

You can also book a call. Let’s map your plan. Let’s make short-term real estate work for your long-term life. Book here.

Thanks for reading. If you enjoy this article, say hello on: Facebook | Stronghold | Email

Casey Russell is the founder of Stronghold Real Estate and a leading short-term rental strategist. After 17 years in the oil and gas industry, Casey transitioned into real estate investing replacing his salary and building a thriving portfolio of high-performing vacation rentals. Today, he helps busy professionals maximize their income and reclaim their time through powerful short-term rental systems and mentorship.

Casey Russell

Casey Russell is the founder of Stronghold Real Estate and a leading short-term rental strategist. After 17 years in the oil and gas industry, Casey transitioned into real estate investing replacing his salary and building a thriving portfolio of high-performing vacation rentals. Today, he helps busy professionals maximize their income and reclaim their time through powerful short-term rental systems and mentorship.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog